There are three ways to house a parent or adult child on your lot in Ontario: an in-law suite that stays part of your home, a legal second unit inside the house, or a garden suite in the yard. Ontario's Planning Act lets you have up to three units on most urban lots as of right, and as of October 2026 Whitby caps a detached unit at 75 m² of floor area and 4.5 m tall under Zoning By-law 1784. Which one fits depends on how independent the household needs to be, and on the money.
Key takeaways
- Ontario's Planning Act stops municipalities from banning three units on an urban residential lot: three in the house, or two in the house and one in a building in the yard.
- The federal Multigenerational Home Renovation Tax Credit is 14.5% of up to $50,000 in costs, a maximum of $7,250, for a secondary unit with its own entrance, kitchen, bathroom and sleeping area.
- Whitby limits a detached additional dwelling unit to 75 m² of floor area and 4.5 m in height under Zoning By-law 1784, while Oshawa caps accessory buildings at 60 m² of ground floor in most zones, per its accessory apartments page.
- In 2021, 9.7% of people in the Oshawa area lived in multigenerational households, against 11.6% in the Toronto area, according to Statistics Canada.
- Toronto garden suite permits list a median cost of $180,000 and an average of about $260,000, and builders told the City real costs often pass $300,000 to $400,000, per the Toronto's May 2025 garden suites report.
Which option fits your family?
The right option depends on how much independence each household needs.
Here is how the three options compare on rules and money:
| In-law suite (part of your home) | Legal second unit in the house | Garden suite in the yard | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Bedroom, bathroom and sitting room added to your home, sharing the kitchen or front door | A self-contained unit with its own kitchen, bathroom and entrance, in a basement, an addition or an upper floor | A self-contained unit in its own building behind the house |
| Counts as a separate dwelling unit | No | Yes | Yes |
| Fire separation between households | Not needed for one dwelling | Needed, per the Ontario Building Code | Separate building |
| Federal multigenerational tax credit | No: the credit needs a self-contained unit | Can qualify | Can qualify |
| Cost range | Our 2026 range: $180,000 to $450,000 for a 300 to 700 sq ft single-storey rear addition | Our 2026 range: $45,000 to $95,000 to legalise a finished basement; $80,000 to $180,000 for a full legal basement apartment | $180,000 median, about $260,000 average by Toronto permit value (Toronto permit data) |
Note: the first two cost ranges are our own for 2026, before 13% HST, and aren't a quote. The garden suite figures are Toronto permit values (2022 to April 2025), which the City says likely understate real costs.
An in-law suite on the main floor suits a parent who needs help nearby, and since it only enlarges your home, it adds no dwelling unit. A legal unit or a garden suite gives each household its own door, with more rules and a bigger bill.
What changes when an in-law suite becomes a legal unit?
The line is the kitchen and the door. Once the space is a self-contained home, with its own cooking, bathroom and sleeping areas behind its own entrance, the building department treats it as a second dwelling unit, and a different set of rules applies.
The Ontario Building Code defines a secondary suite as a self-contained dwelling unit in a residential building with only one other dwelling unit. For a house with a secondary suite, the Code sets out:
- Fire separation. Walls and the floor-ceiling between the units need a fire separation. The Code allows a continuous smoke-tight barrier of 15.9 mm Type X gypsum board in place of a 45-minute rated assembly, and the rating can be waived if the house is sprinklered.
- Ceiling height. At least 1.95 m in the suite, and at least 1.85 m clear under beams and ductwork. Older basements often fail this one, which is when underpinning or lowering the floor enters the budget.
Turning part of a house into a second suite is also a change of use, which needs a permit under the Building Code Act even where little construction happens.
Two provincial rules make the legal route easier. Zoning can't require more than one parking space for each added unit, and can't set a minimum floor area for it (Planning Act). Under O. Reg. 299/19, anyone may live in an additional unit, related or not, so a suite built for your mother today can be rented to someone else later. Our guide to Bill 23 and additional units goes through the provincial rules in full, and the legal basement apartment guide covers the basement route.
What does each option cost?
The spread in basement suite prices above is mostly underpinning, the entrance and the size. In our 2026 ranges, a separate side entrance runs $18,000 to $28,000 and underpinning the full perimeter $60,000 to $120,000. Our permit drawings run $4,000 to $8,000 for a basement apartment, $6,000 to $12,000 for an addition and $5,000 to $15,000 for a garden suite. Those prices cover drawings only: permit fees, HVAC engineering, truss design, committee of adjustment applications and anything unforeseen are extra.
Garden suites cost the most: builders interviewed for Toronto's May 2025 garden suites report said real costs often exceed $300,000 to $400,000.
Money that comes back: the tax credit and development charges
Two things reduce the bill for a self-contained family unit. The first is the federal Multigenerational Home Renovation Tax Credit. It's a refundable credit of 14.5% of up to $50,000 in eligible costs (for the 2025 tax year), a maximum of $7,250 per qualifying renovation. The unit has to be self-contained, with its own entrance, kitchen, bathroom and sleeping area, and it has to be built so a senior, or an adult eligible for the disability tax credit, can live with a qualifying relative. Check your own case against the CRA page before you count on it.
The second is development charges, which a new unit would otherwise attract. Under the Development Charges Act, no development charges apply to a second or third unit in an existing house, or to one unit in a building in the yard, within the three-unit limit. Enlarging your own home with an addition doesn't trigger them either.
Financing a family suite
Plan the financing before the drawings. Toronto's garden suites report found financing was a major barrier for garden suites: there are no resale comparables for an appraiser to use, so many owners refinance the main house, and some abandon the project.
The same report found most Toronto garden suites house family, and rent alone often doesn't cover the cost. Talk to your lender with a rough budget first.
Designing for a parent who will age there
Put the bedroom and a full bathroom on the ground floor if a parent is going to live there for the long term. On a Houzz thread about adding a second floor, one reply flagged the new stairs, "which isn't great for aging in place" (Houzz, about 2014), and suggested keeping a bedroom and bath on the main floor.
That points most multigenerational projects toward a rear addition on the main floor, or a garden suite, rather than a second storey. Inside, the details that matter cost little at framing stage and a lot later: wider doors, a shower without a curb, blocking in the walls for grab bars, a bathroom big enough to turn around in, lever handles, and good light on the path to the door.
The rules in Whitby, Oshawa and Durham Region
In Durham Region, each town writes its own unit rules on top of the provincial ones, and as of October 2026 Whitby and Oshawa differ in ways that change the design:
- Whitby size and setbacks. A detached additional dwelling unit can be up to 75 m² of floor area and 4.5 m tall, set back at least 1.2 m from the interior side and rear lot lines and 3.0 m from an exterior side line (By-law 1784). The entrance needs an unobstructed path at least 1.2 m wide and 2.1 m high. Lots on the Oak Ridges Moraine or in the Greenbelt are limited to one additional unit.
- Whitby registration and fees. Every unit must be registered with the Town under By-law 8156-25, on top of the building permit, and registration costs $268. The permit fee for unit alterations inside a house is $10.65 per m² (2026 fee schedule).
- Whitby charges and incentive. Town and Region development charges don't apply to a unit in an existing home, but education development charges still apply to detached units and to units in homes occupied for less than 12 months, per the Town's ADU page. The Town's ADU Incentive Program reimburses select fees if the complete application is in by 31 December 2026 and the unit is registered by 31 March 2027; see our Whitby ADU incentive guide.
- Oshawa. A lot can have up to three units, at most one in an accessory building. Accessory buildings face three caps, 8% of the lot area, 50% of the house's coverage and 60 m² of ground floor (90 m² in R1-G and R1-H zones), and can be 4.5 m tall, at least 3 m from the house. Each unit needs one extra parking space, and the permit comes with a two-unit house registration (Oshawa accessory apartments). Oshawa issued 338 of those registrations in 2024 (Oshawa open data).
- CLOCA. Both towns sit in the Central Lake Ontario Conservation Authority's area. On a lot near a creek, wetland or the lake shore, an additional dwelling unit also needs a CLOCA permit.
Durham Region issued permits for 999 additional residential units in 2024 and 1,004 in 2025, according to its 2025 building activity review, so a second unit is a routine application here.
How we'd plan it with you
We start at the house. James walks the lot, the basement and the main floor with you, and with whoever is moving in, because their needs set the plan, and we look at what each option would trigger.
Ceara Jarvis and her studio, Juliette Interiors, then design and draw it, a licensed engineer stamps the structure, and we apply for the permit and the town's registration. One crew builds it, we book the inspections as each stage is ready, and we hand it over. For the building itself, see our home additions and garden suites pages.
Explore our case studies on our projects page; the first, Greenwood, was a ten-month renovation in Toronto that we took through design, permit and construction.
Questions
Is an in-law suite the same as a legal secondary suite in Ontario?
An in-law suite and a legal secondary suite are different things in Ontario. An in-law suite that shares the main kitchen or entrance is part of your home, so it is one dwelling unit and needs no fire separation between households.
A secondary suite is a self-contained dwelling unit with its own kitchen, bathroom and entrance. The Ontario Building Code sets fire separation and ceiling height rules for it, and towns like Whitby require it to be registered.
Can I build a garden suite for my parents in Whitby?
Whitby's Zoning By-law 1784 allows a garden suite, which it calls a detached additional dwelling unit, on urban residential lots zoned for houses. It can be up to 75 m² of floor area and 4.5 m tall, set back 1.2 m from the interior side and rear lot lines.
A Whitby garden suite needs a building permit and registration with the Town, which costs $268.
Who qualifies for the Multigenerational Home Renovation Tax Credit?
The Multigenerational Home Renovation Tax Credit covers a renovation that creates a self-contained secondary unit so a senior, or an adult eligible for the disability tax credit, can live with a qualifying relative. The unit needs its own entrance, kitchen, bathroom and sleeping area. The credit is 14.5% of up to $50,000 in eligible costs, a maximum of $7,250 per qualifying renovation, according to the Canada Revenue Agency.
Do I pay development charges for an in-law suite in Durham Region?
In most cases you don't pay development charges for an in-law suite in Durham Region. The Development Charges Act exempts a second or third unit in an existing house and one unit in a building in the yard, and an addition that only enlarges your home doesn't trigger them.
In Whitby, education development charges can still apply to a detached unit, or to a unit in a home occupied for less than 12 months.
If you're weighing these options for your own family, get in touch.
Sources
- Planning Act ontario.ca
- Zoning By-law 1784 media-003-ca.cdn.govstack.com
- Multigenerational Home Renovation Tax Credit canada.ca
- accessory apartments page oshawa.ca
- Statistics Canada www150.statcan.gc.ca
- Toronto's May 2025 garden suites report toronto.ca
- Ontario Building Code publications.gov.on.ca
- Building Code Act ontario.ca
- O. Reg. 299/19 ontario.ca
- Development Charges Act ontario.ca
- Houzz, about 2014 houzz.com
- By-law 8156-25 whitby.ca
- $268 whitby.ca
- 2026 fee schedule media-003-ca.cdn.govstack.com
- Oshawa open data arcgis.com
- CLOCA permit cloca.com
- 2025 building activity review media-003-ca.cdn.govstack.com
